Migrants: centre‑left councils build more collaborative reception networks

Support for the 2020–2021 bill was 39% higher in towns with a history of Resistance. The gap persists after accounting for social and economic differences

Spread the love

Links to the research articles:

Pettrachin A., Caponio T., & Borgna C. (2024). Who is responsible for migrant integration? Contextual political drivers of governance actors’ responsibility frames in small and medium European localities. Local Government Studies, 1–23. https://doi.org/10.1080/03003930.2024.2401916

Caponio T., & Pettrachin A. (2025). Neither multilevel governance nor battleground. Understanding the politics of immigrant integration in small and medium European localities. Governance, e12833. https://doi.org/10.1111/gove.12833

The 2015 refugee crisis brought a significant number of asylum seekers to Europe. National dispersal policies often directed them to small and medium-sized towns and rural areas. Understanding how these communities addressed the challenges of integration is crucial to migration research in the European Union, which—with a few exceptions—has traditionally focused on major cities with a longer history of living with diversity.

Research led by Collegio Carlo Alberto and the University of Turin examines the governance networks that developed after the crisis in 26 localities across seven European countries: Austria, Belgium, Germany, Italy, the Netherlands, Spain and Sweden. The findings clearly show that politics plays a decisive role in shaping how welcoming local approaches to immigration are and how integration processes begin.

Pragmatic expectations, ideological realities

It is tempting to assume that towns and cities address migration challenges pragmatically, seeking to build collaborative networks with higher levels of government—regional or national—and local civil society actors to resolve practical problems effectively. Particularly in small and medium-sized localities, some qualitative studies have emphasised the central role of mayors in negotiating reception and integration arrangements with national governments.

We might therefore expect multilevel governance to emerge, with municipalities building relationships with all the actors able to provide support locally. Yet the research reveals a very different picture. Interactions between local governments in these smaller communities and their regional or national counterparts are sporadic and often conflictual. Relationships with local voluntary and non-profit organisations can also be difficult and strongly influenced by political factors. The political affiliation of the local administration matters, as does the presence of radical-right parties on the municipal council.

Left and right make a difference

To map these governance networks, the researchers surveyed public and private actors involved in refugee integration in each locality. The data were examined using social network analysis, which allowed the researchers to produce visual representations of policy networks across the different communities.

Network graphs mapping the frequency of interactions within integration policy networks in a typical progressive locality and a conservative one. Nodes represent groups of actors, while edges represent interactions between them. Edge weights are proportional to the frequency of exchanges. Node sizes are proportional to their weighted degree, with the nodes displaying the highest weighted degree highlighted in red.

The main finding is that these networks vary considerably depending on the political affiliation of local governments. Municipalities led by centre-left administrations—as shown in Figure 1A—have denser, more collaborative local networks, in which politicians and municipal staff maintain close relationships with civil society associations and non-governmental organisations (NGOs). These administrations often take a central role, actively promoting and coordinating integration policies. In other words, in centre-left municipalities, mayors, councillors with executive responsibilities and/or administrative staff act as brokers within extensive and, above all, cohesive networks.

Network graphs mapping the frequency of interactions within integration policy networks in a typical progressive locality and a conservative one. Nodes represent groups of actors, while edges represent interactions between them. Edge weights are proportional to the frequency of exchanges. Node sizes are proportional to their weighted degree, with the nodes displaying the highest weighted degree highlighted in red.

By contrast, in towns governed by centre-right administrations—as shown in Figure 1B—local governments tend to maintain more fragmented and selective relationships, usually restricted to other levels of government and a small number of voluntary and non-profit organisations. In these settings, NGOs and organisations providing specific services to immigrants take a more central role. Housing agencies are one example: in many countries, these operate as publicly owned companies governed by private law.

Political majorities, fortresses and control

Alongside the survey, in-depth qualitative interviews were conducted in each locality with all the actors involved in the local governance of migrant integration. The aim was to better understand the political dynamics behind the emergence of such different networks under centre-left and centre-right administrations.

Two factors emerged as particularly important: political differences between local administrations and regional or national governing majorities, and the presence of radical-right, anti-immigration parties on municipal councils.

In localities governed by centre-left majorities that face far-right political forces both on municipal councils and in regional and national governments, a form of “fortress syndrome” emerges. Public decision-makers and voluntary and non-profit organisations join forces against anti-immigration parties, strengthening their commitment to integration within the community.

In towns governed by centre-right administrations, by contrast, local governments tend to maintain more fragmented and selective relationships. These are limited to a few voluntary and non-profit organisations contracted to provide the essential reception and integration services required by national law.

When a radical anti-immigration party is present on the municipal council, a so-called “control syndrome” also appears to emerge. Centre-right mayors and politicians seek to prevent potential criticism by limiting the responsibilities delegated to voluntary and non-profit organisations or by directly providing the minimum services required by law. Their aim is to control the allocation of resources considered particularly sensitive, such as access to housing or support for entering the labour market.

European recognition, locally shaped policies

The analysis also shows that small and medium-sized towns, despite being formally recognised as important partners in European migration governance, often remain excluded from decision-making processes at national and/or regional government level.

This isolation weakens their capacity to respond and encourages different local approaches, sometimes in direct conflict with national policies. Rather than a single model of multilevel governance, the research reveals a variety of approaches deeply rooted in local political dynamics.

These findings highlight the fundamental importance of local politics in shaping migrant integration strategies. They also underline the need to take local circumstances carefully into account when designing European and national policies.

Understanding politics to improve integration

Ultimately, managing refugee integration in small and medium-sized European towns is a complex challenge that cannot be addressed through administrative approaches alone.

It requires recognising the decisive influence of local politics, which not only defines the practical objectives of local migration policies but also profoundly shapes relationships between local authorities, civil society actors and higher levels of government.

This understanding is essential to developing more effective and inclusive strategies that can respond to integration needs across Europe’s diverse local communities.

Spread the love
Avatar photo

Tiziana Caponio

Tiziana Caponio is an associate professor of political science in the Department of Cultures, Politics and Society at the University of Turin and a Fellow of Collegio Carlo Alberto. She holds a PhD in Political Science from the University of Florence. Her research examines migration policy, particularly the role of local governments in reception and integration and the relationship between different levels of government. She coordinated Whole-COMM, a European project on migrant integration in small and medium-sized towns and rural areas, and previously chaired IMISCOE’s Standing Committee on Migration Politics and Governance. She now leads Mind-the-NEXUS, an ERC Advanced Grant project investigating the relationship between refugee reception and support for the far right in rural areas across five European countries. With Eduardo Barberis and Ruth McAreavey, she co-edited the Handbook on Migration in Small Towns and Rural Areas, scheduled for publication in November 2026.